Numerous Etsy sellers in Canada are withdrawing their items from the site in response to backlash concerning the integration of artificial intelligence model training into a forthcoming policy change.
In Vancouver, B.C., Tsuki Matsuba is discontinuing her custom stationery offerings from Etsy as the company prepares to implement a new AI policy next month.
“It felt like a slap in the face,” Matsuba remarked.
An update to Etsy’s terms and conditions set to take effect on December 16 includes a clause stating that Etsy, along with its third-party partners and vendors, may utilize sellers’ content to “develop, train, test, and enhance artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.”
KPMG, one of the world’s leading accounting and consulting firms, reported in 2025 that 88 percent of technology executives believe that companies adopting AI will gain a competitive advantage over those that do not.
The survey also indicated that 68 percent of participants anticipate a moderate to extremely high return on investments related to AI, specifically 10 percent or more.
Canadian Response
Having spent seven years in the animation field, Matsuba noted that AI played a significant role in her job loss within that sector.
She worries that Etsy shop owners are “being compelled” to decide between generating holiday revenue and staying on the platform under conditions that permit their content to be used for AI training.
-
How AI goods on Etsy are impacting knitters — and crafters at large
-
Etsy is banning the sale of fur — and Indigenous artisans may suffer most
A growing number of Etsy shop owners across Canada are taking down their products and original artworks due to fears that their creations may be used for AI training.
Ottawa-based artist Tina Nawrocki announced on X that she is “shutting down” her Etsy shop because of the company’s “new exploitative AI practices.”
The artist known as The Calendork from Halifax revealed that they have removed all artwork from their Etsy store but will remain operational due to the “crazy new AI policies.”
‘Should have done more’
James Ossman, Etsy’s head of customer operations, stated in a release that honoring the work of its sellers is “fundamental” to Etsy’s business model.
He emphasized that sellers’ “creative works belong to them,” and asserted that Etsy does not employ that work to train “AI models intended to replicate their original creations or substitute their creativity.”
Ossman mentioned that Etsy intends to keep engaging with sellers regarding the policy adjustment to “clarify our meaning and intention in the Terms.”
He acknowledged that the company “should have done more” to inform sellers about the impending updates to Etsy’s policies.
However, for Matsuba, these discussions will not alter her choice to stop selling her products on the platform.
“My business is entirely free from AI,” she stated, “I do not wish to contribute to the advancement of AI.”
