On Friday, Manchester City announced that it has submitted a “comprehensive” appeal following a report released by an independent commission that outlined significant financial rule violations by the Premier League club, marking one of the largest controversies in English soccer history.
A brief statement from the club asserted, “The club’s firm position is that there are clear material errors in the opinion regarding law, principle, and fact, rendering it unsafe on multiple grounds.”
Throughout the protracted case, which began in 2018, City has maintained its innocence. A pivotal moment occurred on Tuesday when the Premier League announced a verdict declaring the Abu Dhabi-controlled club “guilty of all charges related to serious breaches” of its financial regulations from 2009 to 2018.
City has not yet faced any penalties. The Premier League has indicated that potential repercussions may include a reprimand, financial penalties, points deduction, or, in the most severe scenario, expulsion from the league. Historically, no team has ever been expelled from England’s top division.
-
Manchester City guilty of almost all 115 financial charges, Premier League says in explosive verdict
Club officials indicated their intention to appeal, with the formal submission made on Thursday evening, just before the deadline on Friday.
City reiterated its claim of innocence, stating, “A comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists to support all of its positions related to this case,” echoing phrases from earlier statements.
The Premier League confirmed that City has “appealed the decision” made by the commission, noting that the appeal hearing “will remain private and confidential until the outcome can be publicly disclosed.”
Appeal hearing expected to conclude within 12 weeks
According to Premier League regulations, the chair of the three-member investigatory panel that ruled against City is responsible for appointing the new appeal board, which will also consist of three members, one of whom “shall have held judicial office,” as stipulated by the league’s rules.
The appeal hearing is set to take place within 12 weeks of the appeal’s submission and cannot last longer than five consecutive days.
The league indicated, “An appeal board has broad discretion regarding the appeal and may permit it, reject it, or issue any other order they deem appropriate.”
Any penalties related to this case will be handled in a separate, confidential hearing by the investigatory panel. It remains unclear whether sanctions can be applied before the appeal’s conclusion.
The Premier League has stated its desire for the process to be resolved “as soon as possible.”
City’s $1B financial violations involved ‘sham’ commercial agreements
The commission found that City had systematically violated the Premier League’s financial regulations for nearly a decade, which Richard Masters, the league’s chief executive, described as the most significant disciplinary matter in the league’s history.
The investigatory panel determined that City inflated its revenue by over $1 billion US from 2009 to 2018 through what the league labeled as “sham” commercial agreements, thereby circumventing financial fair-play regulations that restricted competing clubs and enabling City to acquire some of the world’s top players.
This financial strategy laid the groundwork for a prolonged and unprecedented era of success, during which City transformed the landscape of the world’s most popular soccer league, winning eight league titles between 2012 and 2024.
The commission found that City was responsible for almost all of the 115-plus violations: 80 for alleged financial misconduct from 2009 to 2018 and an additional 35 from 2018 to 2023 for purportedly failing to cooperate with the investigation.
Sponsorship funding likely to be a focal point in appeal
Part of City’s appeal will likely center on how its sponsorship agreements based in Abu Dhabi were financed.
The commission found that sponsors in Abu Dhabi contributed only £119.25 million ($158.4 million) of the £949.94 million ($1.26 billion) reported in the club’s accounts, with the remaining £830.69 million ($1.1 billion) funded by the Abu Dhabi United Group, the private entity owned by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, who acquired City in 2008.
Sheikh Mansour is part of the ruling family of the United Arab Emirates.
City argued that “no part” of these agreements was financed by the ADUG, claiming instead that the Abu Dhabi government, which owned the sponsors, provided funding “from time to time.” Thus, City believes that the source of this additional funding was misinterpreted, as stated by the commission.
The panel rejected City’s explanation as false, concluding that it was “fabricated well after the fact” to obscure the funding source.
In an internal video shared with City staff, which was obtained by Sky News, City CEO Ferran Soriano stated, “The entire Premier League case against us is built on a single false claim: that the owner’s personal funds were secretly injected into the club via sponsors from Abu Dhabi. This is simply untrue.”
On Friday, the Football Association, the regulatory body for soccer in England, expressed its concerns regarding the “integrity” of the sport in light of the scandal.
In its initial response, the FA stated, “The decision made by the independent commission has significant implications for the integrity of the game. We are carefully reviewing the decision and its ramifications and will take appropriate action where necessary.”
The FA added that it will “continue to monitor developments closely” and will refrain from further comments due to the ongoing proceedings.
Prime Minister Burnham clarifies his statements
The Manchester City case is currently undergoing a disciplinary process and is not a criminal matter. On Thursday, a bipartisan committee of lawmakers urged Britain’s tax authority to examine the findings of the independent panel for any potential tax-related concerns.
Dame Meg Hillier, chair of the Treasury Committee, wrote to the permanent secretary of His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC), requesting, “While I understand that taxpayer confidentiality may limit your disclosures, I would appreciate reassurance from HMRC that you recognize the importance of these issues and the public interest in this case.”
In another instance highlighting the scandal’s wide-ranging impact, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham has faced repeated inquiries about his opinion on the situation.
On Wednesday, Burnham expressed concern about the potential loss of City’s Abu Dhabi ownership from English soccer, stating that they have been a “significant partner in the development of modern Manchester” and in establishing City as a global force, while also indicating he would not interfere in the process.
Burnham previously served as the mayor of Manchester.
On Thursday, Downing Street sought to clarify that the prime minister considers the ruling to be “serious and that there cannot be any implication that anyone is above the rules.”
Burnham’s office emphasized in a statement, “If wrongdoing is confirmed, those responsible should face the appropriate consequences,” while reiterating that the independent process is still ongoing.