Dame Prue Leith has been a fixture on The Great British Bake Off for nine years, where she has evaluated numerous cakes and crowned several cooking talents with the title of star baker alongside Paul Hollywood. Initially stepping in to replace Dame Mary Berry, she recently revealed her decision to step down.

In a statement, she expressed her gratitude for her time on the show, having judged over 400 challenges across nine seasons. At 86 years old, she felt it was the right moment to take a step back and pursue other interests, including enjoying her garden during summers. She bid farewell to her fellow judge Paul, along with Alison, Noel, and the production teams at Love Productions and Channel 4, acknowledging how fortunate she was to be part of the show.

As fans pondered who might fill her shoes, several prominent names emerged as potential replacements. Rosemary Shrager, known for her culinary expertise showcased on programs like Rosemary Shrager’s School for Cooks and Cooking With The Stars, garnered support from fans who saw her as a suitable successor.

Caroline Waldegrave, Lady Waldegrave of North Hill, who previously stood in for Prue during SU2C specials, also received praise from viewers, with some suggesting she could be a strong replacement. Similarly, the idea of acclaimed cookery icon Delia Smith taking over gained traction among fans, with some calling for the return of Dame Mary Berry.

Angela Hartnett, a Michelin-starred chef recognized for her appearances on various culinary shows, including Great British Menu and Hell’s Kitchen, was another name floated as a potential judge. Nadiya, renowned for winning the sixth series of The Great British Bake Off and later hosting her own cooking shows, was also a popular choice among fans.

Meanwhile, Rustie Lee, known for her presence on TV-am, and Lennie, who has showcased her culinary skills on the Table Manners podcast, were suggested as potential replacements by fans, each appreciated for their unique talents and personalities.